Monday, September 26, 2005

It Ain't all 2.0 Ajax Love

I'm loving Paul Kedrosky, Infectious Greed blog, who also likes comparing dotcom vs web 2.0 (my favourite sociological exercise) and dud vs good ajax applications (2.0 capitalism screening techniques) He uses Desktop.com - another app I had forgot about pre-Long Tail and google scrip.. Paul says : "So, what was wrong with Desktop.com? I’ll start by naming three things:

  • Performance. Waiting for Desktop.com to send all the relevant code to my desktop was deathly, like being in an airplane’s row 25 at 11pm at night and waiting for everyone in front of you to disembark.
  • Apps. Desktop.com had a nice desktop, no surprise, but it didn’t have apps. It wanted people to use it as an o/s and build apps for it, which forces developers to make bets that most developers don’t want to make.
  • Money. The Desktop.com people had no idea how they were were going to charge for the product. At least as importantly, they had few (no) examples they could point to of comparable products that people paying for as a service.

Have the above three things changed? Yes, more or less. Performance is far better for Ajax apps than it was for Desktop.com; Ajax apps are apps, not an o/s; and people are more comfortable paying for software as a service. Does that augur in favor of a new generation of Ajax apps? Sure, but the naive mistake people make is in thinking that I want a word processor, spreadsheet, or a presentation program that is the same as the one that I currently have, but that uses Ajax under the hood. Well, I don’t. Matter of fact, I don’t care about that any more than I care whether my Hyundai Santa Fe (there, I said it) has a Wankel rotary engine. I just don’t care, and nor do most people. What I really want from Ajax apps is for them to do stuff that it’s too hard to do with binary apps. I want them to be sensibly integrated with online resources; I want them to support realtime collaboration. I want them to do different stuff from Word/Excel/Powerpoint, not just do the same thing with a different engine under the hood."

|
IMG_1715.JPG
Originally uploaded by phreak125.