Monday, September 26, 2005

The Highest CPC doesnt equal Highest Love


(love them)
Originally uploaded by kH@N.
I was in a meeting today with an up and coming Public Search Engine in Australia, and the topic of "modelling" Web 2.0 + CPC's came up. (separately i think ;) Mainly in terms of some established high value verticals where merchants and consumers trying to sell "expensive" products (6 figure jobs, beemers, google' vested pads in mountainview) are being ripped off by classifieds sites with fixed fee listing prices : Either fixed amount per listing (eg $100 per job for 1 month) or fixed CPM's / Sponsorship Fees for Ad Placements (which can be linked back to an indicative CPM and contractual obligation to deliver set impressions etc) Anyway, if I think of Search in its traditional PageRank sense, I'd rather drive around Australia and make ends meet than consult to clients on SEO strategies. It's Yesterdays Web by definition (how many people have ever linked to you etc as the basis for the search algorithm vs recency + popularity measures for rss behaviour in last 12 hours for e.g) But speak to me about RSS Syndication Strategies. Its like the SEO industry in 1995. Clients who ask "How do I get my RSS Feed out to the highest amount of people at the cheapest cost in the quickest time ?" A. No client has asked that, really, not in Australia yet. B. Mention Scoble, Tablet PC, Shock + Awe, and switching from Windows to Mac - if you work for a competitor and do it in a non-advertorial way) and that will help drive traffic according to ScobesSnr himself.. C. All of the Above.. Anyway... Thats different (cue : if u want a cheap way to hire me - talk 2.0 stuff then make me do 1.0 things !)

Nice "message board" (how 1.0) on WebMasterWorld, which I admit was one of the few sites (along with internetnews.com) I read during the early 2000's crash. (man danah has me thinking about the web 2.0 crash after her post) The context was about Google blocking sites (I wont even mention my ajax scraping tool that would strip the content/rss from what u r reading and integrating it "blog this" into your blog platform ! : "Google *should* be aware that blocking in fact DOES increase income for many of us, hence the official blurb is misleading, and innacurate. It's interesting that they are admitting that they don't target ads based on bid price - something that has been said in this forum repeatedly. Many people believe that Google targets the highest bidding ads. Google don't seem in too much of a hurry to correct this misunderstanding. The other point is that the data they use on ad performance is how the ads perform ON THE NETWORK AS A WHOLE and NOT how they perform on your site - a massive difference IMHO. The difficulty that Google's targetting algorythm causes is that it often removes ads it thinks are low paying, and replaces them with ads it thinks are high paying. These decisions are based on performance on OTHER WEBSITES - not yours! If your website is about bright orange widgets with stripes, then logically ads trying to sell bright orange widgets with stripes would be the obvious choice. However, as they don't perform well elsewhere on the network the chances of you seeing them are lessened - despite the fact that they may perform very well on your site! And if you DO see them, the chances of them being removed and replaced by something irrelevant are high! Many of us here have highly focussed websites, and many of us here are experienced webmasters that know where our traffic comes from, why they come and what ads might or might not appeal to our visitors.

We know that having ads that are highly irrelevant will not work for either advertisers or us. However, the target bot gets it spectacularly wrong quite often. For example, my website is aimed at middle aged family men, and Goole has been targetting acne cream adverts. Therefore we block wrongly targetted ads. So what ads do Google replace the good payers that work on YOUR site with? Yup, you guessed it - scrapers mostly. Scrapers do have a higher CTR than genuine advertisers selling goods and services, therefore they do well in the quality score. However, they are of no use to anyone because they don't pay well. They can't! What they are trying to achieve is siphon traffic off cheaply, and get visitors to click on more expensive ads on their site. Ever noticed that scrapers very often block other scrapers from appearing on their sites? Google's algorythm allows them to do this by placing their higher ctr ads instead of real advertisers selling goods and services. They did it to me again yesterday. One of my regulars was removed and replaced with a site having an adsense block, an adwords block and another adsense block just to make sure! In addition, it had a big ebay ad offering new and used vasectomy reversals. Content? Scraped. These ads DO NOT pay well - remove them. What Google aren't saying is what the long term effect of allowing their chosen placements of scrapers does. EPC will slide, and smartpricing will downgrade your site for the good payers too. Therefore, an advertiser that is willing to pay well for a quality lead THAT YOUR SITE IS PROVIDING THEM WITH only pays marginally above minimum. By keeping scrapers off, my EPC has risen sixfold over the last two months since I have been blocking some of the stupid placements and all made for adsense sites. Bottom line income is up by 30% plus and rising. I'm seeing genuine advertisers, and although they don't have such a high CTR as the scrapers, they pay WAY more, and smartpricing now thinks my site is worth a lot more than it did when it was carrying the scrapers and junk adsense chose to place."