Sunday, January 15, 2006

$6m in Funding to be the Flickr of Blogging

Gather.com is the new place where bloggers get paid to blog, except they aren't yet getting paid. Maybe that will happen in March as they say. (update : link to article appears to now require registration) Or they will at least get credits from online retailers by then. Alot of people bitch about content on the edge, and distributed conversations, and mainly it ends up being a linguistics exercise between VC bloggers, ex-Media citizen journalists and post rich, cash poor bloggers.




I like the Gawker and Calacanis model of paying writers, producers, media hackers, ex-journalists, bloggers or whatever you want to call "User Generated Content Creators" a lower per word industry base salary + bonusing based on above forecast eyeballs and clicks. I think those numbers could get much lower for those that wanted to provide basic incentives to people who didnt want to be building someone else's brand, but were willing to share rather that assign the non-revenue upside. The Gawker/Weblogs model though is still a job/contract and you take a punt that you (personally as editor "ooh im an editor now !") can build the brand and heck freedom and expression count for something.

Gather.com is different to the Denton world, its trying to appeal to people like me. So lets use me as a case study. Would I switch my content efforts to gather.com ? I'd like to earn some money blogging yes, but what about my technorati rank, and the personal brand I am building ? Wouldn't benbarren.gather.com be a brand extension for me that would in effect diminish my potential impact to get my voice heard ? (like my ghost towns @ benbarren.blogs.com, benbarren.wordpress.com + benbarren.suprglu.com are) If I take this a step further, if I was serious about blogging I could use adsense, adbrite + blogads, where I could receive 70% of "my" revenue and have a kick-ass business, I owned. If someone wanted me to allocate my future content streams and discount them to a present value which entailed a switch to gather.com, what would it really take ? mmm, new paragraph while I think.

Gather.com, to switch, I'd want a "content generation tool" that was better than Typepad, that gave me the pro-like-package for free (and ideally it would be a VIP pre alpha tool like Calacanis's BlogSmith which was exclusive and I could showoff to other bloggers who might not have it) I'd want my own domain name of choice (eg benbarren.com or something without a subdomain eg benbarren.gtr, benbarren.be is cheap) I'd want some excellent edge of legal linklove to locknload my page rank. I'd want my posts to be optimised the bejesus out of so my sitemeter /google analytics/ technorati rating increased dramatically and then gave me ancillary marketing benefits because I'd have more comments and hence people to speak to about REAL BUSINESS. And then I'd want a great commercial deal. So you'd match or exceed current industry standards : eg You'd pay me 60-75% of ad revenue generated. And you'd know how to maximise the sponsorships, CPM's, CPC and CPA's so that your yield was higher than competitors. (So I'd get 75% of MORE) Now 6 or 7 out of 10 of those types of features would get me to switch to Gather. And thousands others like me would switch too. Gather.com would then jump up the blog network rankings like Federated Media and Web 2.0 Workgroup within one month of launching your beta. Happy Charlene Li. Happy first round investors. Noone likes a ghost town, and like the first weekend of a Hollywood movie, the internet audience speaks farely quick. (the gather UI is a bit busy, but looks nice and post-digg : there's alot on each page tho, as if they're not sure what is core functionality driving page, but i like it)

One more point - If you look at a Gather.com member's home page : This seems less a page for me or my "identity". Now this worries me because to get the "viral effect" people need to be able promote a page they're proud of. That reflects them. That is them. Look at MySpace and MSN Spaces. User Home Pages there look awful to some outsiders, but they allow users to design them as badly as they want. And then they tell their friends, and they get pages they design badly too. Woohoo, we have a Community ! On a Gather user home page for example the left navigation (bland top down topics such as arts, entertainment etc and then annoying folksonomic "tags".. takeover the whole left navigation - doh let me delete them if I dont want them there) Horizontally there is a Web 2.0 Nav Bar (View, Publish, Connect, Communicate etc) which dominates that space. Once you put the member posts in the centre column, you arent left with much screen real estate for customisation, let alone the raft of templates on something like tagworld.com. For gather.com, it's OK to say you dont want to be like MySpace and Spaces (because you are going for the "knitting, gated community" audience), but there are still some big lessons from our IM'ing tweens. 160,000 of them a day in the case of MySpace. As there are with some of the template upgrades of WordPress 2.0 and the motivation for that.

Gather.com members also dont like hyperlinks I've found, do you think I should ?

Jim Manzi : "Yet another key challenge emerges. How will a user-generated media site manage its own editorial function? Gather, with its member-contributors, has an opportunity to create a new kind of community. Will Gather be a democracy? I can't imagine that working. There cannot be some mob rule over content. There will necessarily be "rules" or community agreements defined and negotiated by the members (Gather: The Community) with some assistance from Gather: The Company. I think that Gather can emerge as a new " Republic of Information. " A "Republic"? It means a way of "owning" that combines sharing collectively and being responsible (and responsive) individually. It defines a place where users self-select and self-organize as the power shifts from the center to the edges and member-contributors help define their own futures and the future of their shared space."